Is Coke better than Apple Juice – Fructose content edition

This is a simple conclusion of my previous post on the fructose content of fruits: neither Coke (the regular variety) nor apple juice is really a healthy drink, but arguably Coke is healthier than apple juice in the grand scheme of things… 

Now before I get flamed in the comments, I do understand that the aspect I will discuss is only one aspect in the comparison, and there might be others. For example, and in no particular order,

  • Coke contains caffeine,
  • apple juice might contain other valuable nutrients,
  • apple juice can be prolonged with water

I will ignore all of those arguments in this post, simply as my conclusion is that neither Coke nor (pure) apple juice are suitable for drinking in large quantities (ie they are treats, like ice cream, or dessert). Also, it should be clear already that “Coke” is used as a placeholder, and mutatis mutandis (cool word, hein?) the same reasoning applies to all kind of soft drinks. Now you might not find that surprising, but until I did run the numbers below I still thought that something like apple juice is borderline acceptable for my daughter, whilst Coke really is not.

Now as to the numbers. For simplicity, I will compare 1 can of Coke with the same amount of apple juice (330ml), and I will also provide the numbers per liter for reference. Looking at the data, Coke contains about 11g sugar per 100ml (sources for US here and UK here). The sugar content in apple juice is actually pretty much the same (see eg here), as is the one of most major sodas and fruit juices (one exception being grape juice, which is about 18g/100ml).

For simplicity I will ignore the difference between US sodas that are sweetened with HFCS (55% fructose, 45% glucose) and European sodas (of the same brands) that tend to be sweetened with sucrose (effectively 50% glucose, 50% fructose) and will in the following assume the latter. So for Coke (and many other sodas) the sugar content is 36g/can or 110g/l, giving a fructose content of about 18g/can and 55g/l.

For apple juice it is probably safe to assume that the ratio between fructose and glucose is the same as in the fruit, ie 70%. So 1 can (or 330ml) / 1l of apple juice will provide the same amount of overall sugars, ie 36g/can and 110g/l. However, the effective fructose content of this will be at 25g/can and 77g/l respectively. This should be compared to the maximal intake of 50g fructose / day suggested  in the other post. It should also be noted that the 50g number is for adults, and whilst naive scaling might or might not work, it is probably a good first guess to assume that (a) a liver half the size can only deal safely with half the fructose, and (b) that the size of the liver of a child is roughly determined by its lean body weight. So if we assume that the 50g suggestion holds for the 60kg average (lean) adult, then it should be half that for a lean child of 30kg.

I dont want to get too hung up on the detailed numbers here, as it is very clear that whatever the exact result is, any meaningful amount of either Coke or apple juice will quickly use up (or significantly exceed) every reasonable daily fructose threshold, especially for kids, and especially when consumed very quickly, in a highly bio-available format. My clear conclusion: either of them should be avoided, except in very rare occasions as a treat (and then in lieu of, and not together with ice cream). However, from a fructose point of view (and I now believe that one is key), Coke is actually more healthy (less unhealthy actually) than apple juice.

One might argue of course that sodas with non-sugar sweeteners are the way to go, but this is the subject of a future post…

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Is Coke better than Apple Juice – Fructose content edition

  1. Pingback: Healthy fruits – Fructose content edition | Thor Falk

  2. You don’t consider the salt – yes, salt! – in a can of coke, which is considerable. Sneaky, too, since Coke also contains caffeine, which is a diuretic. So, you drink a can of Coke, the caffeine pulls water out of your system and the salt just increases your thirst further. Did i say sneaky? I meant diabolical!

  3. Apple juice also has a rather high sodium content though…

    I don’t know, I think there is something to say for the fact that applejuice is at least kind of hydrating as opposed to coke which really is not. My kids options for drinks are water, water and more water, exceptions are made when we are out to eat or they are at a friend’s house or party, and my oldest (10) does drink milk at breakfast and lunch while at school, but the boys (9, 5 and 4) hate milk, the youngest is not in school yet but the other 2 either bring a thermos straw cup of water or buy bottled water from the cafeteria. I also allow the oldest to drink tea, non caffeinated, I’d allow the boys to as well, but they don’t like it. I just think it is a good idea to go for those first few years, before they have school parties and the like, to try our hardest to make them like water as their everyday drink and see juice and pop as something to assume occasionally, as a treat, in hopes that it will be a life long thing.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s